cardiff castle, medieval, norman keep, norman, historic, wales, architecture, history, landmark, tourism, welsh, capital city, cardiff, cardiff castle, cardiff castle, cardiff, cardiff, cardiff, cardiff, cardiff
Photo by MichaelPGore_1984 on Pixabay

Audience research

Planning bilingual vertical video for Cardiff brands

A practical look at bilingual vertical video for Cardiff brands, covering language choices, subtitles, compliance, scheduling and campaign testing.

What to take away

  • Vertical video for Cardiff brands is rarely one assetpublic sector and media teams usually need an English cut and a Welsh cut, or one cut carrying both languages.
  • Welsh language creative choices come down to voiceover, on-screen text and subtitles. Dubbing, dual-language captions and burned-in Welsh text all carry different cost and accessibility trade-offs.
  • The Welsh Language Commissioner sets expectations through Welsh language standards, and those standards apply to how you publish video, not just to written documents.
  • Cardiff has a workable pool of Welsh-language production and translation providers, so translation does not have to sit with the editor.

What bilingual English and Welsh vertical video means for Cardiff brands

Cardiff is Wales' media and public sector centre. That shapes the brief before anyone opens a camera. A housing association, a health board, a university or a devolved government body in Cardiff often has to publish in both languages, and short-form video is now part of that publishing.

Choose your bilingual video format

Which language leads the cut?

Yes

Welsh-first -> Welsh-speaking audiences

No

English-first -> everyone else

Bilingual does not mean one video with two soundtracks. Vertical video is watched at speed, often with sound off, so the languages have to share a small screen. The practical question is which language leads and which language travels alongside it.

Most Cardiff teams land in one of three places. A Welsh-first cut for Welsh-speaking audiences. An English-first cut for everyone else. Or a single cut with Welsh voiceover and English subtitles, which is common where budget only covers one edit.

Each choice changes your audience target. If you are building the audience profile for a campaign, do it separately for each language rather than averaging the two. Our guide to building a short form video target audience covers how to split that work without doubling the research.

One caution. Do not treat Welsh as a translation layer added at the end. If the script is written for English word order and then translated, the Welsh voiceover will sound stilted and the on-screen text will not fit the frame.

Welsh language creative choices: voiceover, on-screen text and subtitling

Voiceover is the most expensive bilingual choice and the one audiences notice most. A Welsh voiceover read by a first-language speaker lands differently from a read by a confident second-language speaker. For public sector campaigns, the former is usually expected.

Costs are quoted per project, not per language. Voiceover is usually priced per finished minute or per session, translation per 1,000 words and timed subtitle files per finished minute. Typical ranges vary with script length, turn-around, voice direction and the number of platform versions, so ask for a quote in those units.

Voiceover, on-screen text, subtitles

Voiceover

Cost
Most expensive
Flexibility
Low
Audience impact
Noticed most
Welsh risk
Stilted if translated
Control
First-language reader

On-screen text

Cost
Cheaper
Flexibility
High
Audience impact
Read at speed
Welsh risk
Longer words wrap
Control
Keep lines short

Subtitling

Cost
Mid
Flexibility
Medium
Audience impact
Accessibility load
Welsh risk
Weaker auto-captions
Control
Upload subtitle files

On-screen text is cheaper and more flexible. Welsh headlines, English headlines, or Welsh headline with English support line all work in 9:16, provided you keep each line short. Welsh words are often longer than their English equivalents, so a headline that fits in English may wrap in Welsh.

Subtitling carries the accessibility load. Burned-in subtitles are reliable but cannot be turned off, which matters for viewers who find captions distracting. Platform captions can be toggled but are auto-generated unless you upload a file, and Welsh auto-captioning remains weaker than English.

BSI's BS 8878:2010, Web accessibility — Code of practice, provides a framework for web accessibility, while subtitle accuracy still needs a separate bilingual review. Its standards catalogue is a starting point when setting an accessibility approach; it does not replace testing captions in Welsh and English.

If your team already has a review process for English assets, extend it rather than replacing it. The short form video quality checklist we use for English teams maps cleanly onto Welsh variants once you add a language-accuracy step.

A worked example

A Cardiff health board wants one 20-second vertical video about winter vaccination. Budget covers one shoot, one edit and two language versions.

  1. Script in Welsh first, with the English adaptation written second, so the Welsh read is natural.
  2. Shoot the presenter speaking Welsh to camera, then English to camera, same framing and lighting.
  3. Edit two 9:16 versions with identical pacing, so performance differences reflect language, not craft.
  4. Upload Welsh and English subtitle files to each edit rather than relying on auto-captions.
  5. Publish the Welsh cut first to the Welsh-language channel, then the English cut, and label both clearly.

The result is two comparable assets, one shoot day, and data you can actually act on.

Welsh Language Commissioner expectations and compliance points

The Welsh Language Commissioner is the body that oversees Welsh language standards for public bodies in Wales. If your organisation is named in those standards, they apply to your video output as part of your published communications, not only to PDFs and web pages.

The duties sit in the Welsh Language Standards (No. 1) Regulations 2015. Standard 46 requires publicity material to be available in Welsh, and Standard 47 requires you not to treat Welsh less favourably. For covered organisations, campaign videos published on websites and social media should be considered as part of their publicity material.

Welsh Language Commissioner compliance

  • Record how each campaign was produced in both languages
  • Show Welsh version was not added after sign-off
  • Give Welsh equal prominence on screen and titles
  • Avoid small Welsh subtitle under large English headline
  • Check Equality Act 2010 before calling Welsh optional
  • Check ad disclosure and consent before boosting

In practice that means a few things for Cardiff marketing teams. You need a clear record of how each campaign was produced in both languages, and you need to be able to show that the Welsh version was not an afterthought added after sign-off.

Compliance also touches how you present the two languages. Giving Welsh equal prominence on screen, in titles and in descriptions is the safer habit. Treating Welsh as a small subtitle under a large English headline is the pattern most likely to attract criticism.

Separately, language and audience treatment sit inside equality law. The Equality Act 2010 prohibits discrimination in the provision of services, and its full text is the reference point when a team argues that a Welsh version is optional.

Finally, remember that paid promotion adds another layer. If you are boosting bilingual video, check your disclosure and consent position before approval, as set out in our guide to UK ad disclosure and consent.

  • Welsh version scripted, not translated line by line from English
  • First-language Welsh voice talent booked and credited
  • Subtitle file uploaded for both languages, not auto-generated
  • Welsh given equal prominence in titles, thumbnails and descriptions
  • Internal record kept of the bilingual production process
  • Paid promotion disclosure checked before boosting

What to look for in Welsh production and translation support

For Cardiff teams, shortlist Welsh-language production and translation support against the same brief. Availability of Welsh voice talent can affect delivery, so check capacity early.

Questions for Welsh suppliers

  • Who reads the Welsh script, and are they first-language?
  • Can you supply timed subtitle files in both languages?
  • Can you deliver 9:16 vertical edits without re-framing?
  • Can you handle a series, not just one 20-second cut?
  • Do you understand TikTok vs YouTube framing and captions?

Look for providers who can do both translation and voice direction. A translator who never hears the script read aloud will produce text that is accurate but unspeakable. A studio with in-house Welsh talent avoids that gap.

Verify these credentials before you shortlist:

Shortlisting providers

  • First-language Welsh voice talent, named and credited.
  • Timed subtitle files in both languages, not auto-generated captions.
  • 9:16 delivery without re-framing a widescreen source.
  • Translation and voice direction handled in house or under one contract.
  • Capacity for a series, not just one 20-second cut.

When you compare suppliers, keep the channel plan in view. A provider who understands where each cut is going will frame and caption differently for TikTok than for YouTube. Our comparison of how to build a short form video channel strategy without spreading your team thin is a useful companion here.

Scheduling bilingual vertical video across TikTok, Instagram and YouTube

Scheduling two languages across three platforms can double your publishing load if you let it. The fix is to decide which platform leads each language before you build the calendar.

Platform roles for bilingual video

TikTok

Best for
Welsh-first cut
Audience
Younger Welsh speakers
Text room
Tight placement
Publishing
Welsh first

Instagram

Best for
Both languages
Audience
Mixed
Text room
Caption field
Publishing
Middle

YouTube

Best for
Separate uploads
Audience
Targeted campaigns
Text room
Ad formats
Publishing
Run side by side

TikTok rewards native-feeling content and is where a Welsh-first cut can perform well with younger Welsh-speaking audiences. TikTok's own creative guidance is worth reading before you lock a bilingual format, because the platform's expectations for text placement shape what fits on screen.

Instagram sits in the middle. Reels handle both languages comfortably, and the caption field gives you room for a short bilingual description that TikTok does not.

YouTube is where the two-language approach pays off differently. Separate Welsh and English uploads can be targeted as distinct campaigns, and YouTube's advertising formats support running them side by side rather than competing in one auction.

A simple weekly pattern works for most Cardiff teams. Publish the Welsh cut first on the platform where that audience is strongest, hold the English cut for the following day, and keep the posting times consistent so the data stays comparable.

General creative discipline still applies. The IAB UK's introduction to creative best practice is a sensible baseline for both language versions, particularly on early framing and first-second clarity.

Testing Welsh and English variants against audience data

Test the two languages as separate campaigns, not as one campaign with a language toggle. Mixed reporting hides the thing you are trying to learn.

Testing bilingual variants

  • Test Welsh and English as separate campaigns
  • Set the same success measure for both
  • Give each variant enough runtime before judging
  • Watch completion rate
  • Watch subtitle engagement
  • Watch comment language
  • Feed results back into persona work

Set the same success measure for both. If the Welsh cut is judged on reach and the English cut on click-through, you will always conclude that one language underperforms, and you will be wrong.

Give each variant enough runtime before you judge it. Small Welsh-speaking audiences mean slower data accumulation, and a three-day comparison will usually just measure noise.

Watch three signals. Completion rate, which shows whether the language choice held attention. Subtitle engagement, where the platform reports it. And comment language, which tells you who actually turned up.

Feed the results back into your persona work rather than leaving them in a dashboard. Building short form video buyer personas from evidence rather than assumption is the difference between a bilingual strategy and a bilingual habit.

Common questions

Does every Cardiff campaign need a Welsh version?
No. It depends on whether your organisation is covered by Welsh language standards and on who the campaign is for. Public bodies in Wales are far more likely to need one than a private brand selling outside Wales.
Can we use auto-generated captions for Welsh?
You can, but accuracy is weaker than for English and errors are more visible to first-language speakers. Uploading a timed subtitle file is the safer route for any Welsh-language cut.
Is a Welsh voiceover always better than Welsh on-screen text?
Not always. Voiceover carries more weight with Welsh-speaking audiences but costs more and limits your edit. On-screen text is cheaper and works when sound is off.
How many Welsh-language suppliers should we shortlist?
Two or three is realistic for most Cardiff teams. Availability of first-language voice talent is the main constraint, so a backup supplier is worth having.

More in Audience research